Wednesday, April 30, 2008


Curtis McCarty Speaks in Knoxville

On Thursday, April 24, I picked up Curtis McCarty from the Knoxville airport. We locked eyes as he passed through the security checkpoint and he flashed me a peace sign. As we shook hands, I tensed up--Curtis McCarty spent nearly 19 years on Oklahoma's death row for a crime he didn't commit. Would we talk about anything other than death row? Would we talk about death row at all? Would we have anything in common? As we walked to the car, Curtis and I spoke of our mutual fondness for the Stone Temple Pilots and Rage Against the Machine and our disdain for text messaging and pop music.

I told Curtis that we'd have some time to relax before our speaking engagement at the University of Tennessee Knoxville Law School. He grinned. "If there's anything I know how to do, it's killing time." The weather was pleasant so I gave Curtis a walking tour of the UT Campus. Students were out and about playing frisbee, volleyball, and baseball. I only graduated from college eleven months ago, so this was a familiar sight. Curtis's educational experience was different. He completed junior high, but dropped out of high school. While on death row, Curtis kept up with his studies in science and technology and educated himself on the laws dictating his life. When he speaks, its quickly apparent that he's deeply intelligent. His words are chosen carefully. It's almost as if he speaks with the belief that every sentence could be his last.

Before Curtis was to speak at the law school, I told him that there would be attorneys, law professors, and students in the audience. This was an important event for TCASK; we're always looking to build relationships with schools. The room filled to almost 70 people. It was a Thursday evening in the midst of final exams.

Curtis began by immediately taking responsibility for ending up on death row. He shamefully recounted the juvenile history of drugs and crime which led him to associate with the murdered individual. To Curtis, his poor choices prior to his incarceration played a large role in his ending up in prison.

Yet, the state of Oklahoma is ultimately responsible for sending an innocent man to death row. The case of Curtis McCarty is riddled with problems that suggest he was wrongfully convicted in the murder of Pam Willis: suppressed evidence, destroyed evidence, and perjured testimony. Curtis spoke about his case with the knowledge and eloquence of a law professor. The students were impressed; some said Curtis knew more about death penalty law than they did, and were eager to bring him back for the UT Law Review Death Penalty Symposium next year.

The next day I took Curtis to speak at two assemblies at Knoxville Catholic High School. Again, this was an important event for us: Creating a strong base of Catholic support in Eastern Tennessee has always been a priority for TCASK. This time, Curtis spoke in a manner that suited the ages of his audience. Rather than sifting through the legal problems pervading his case, he focused on the personal story of his life.

"The only two people on this entire Earth who would testify on behalf of the worthiness of my life were my two parents. I have never been more ashamed in my entire life after I saw my mom tearfully pleading for the jury to spare me. I was still sentenced to death."

He shared photos taken at five year intervals when he was on death row. "It's tough to look at these photos because all I see are missed birthdays, graduations, soccer games, and weddings." The Principal told me afterwards that he saw specific students that he knew to be drug users hanging onto Curtis's every word. He said that we need to bring back Curtis every year.

The death penalty system is broken. 128 individuals have been released from death rows nationwide when evidence of their innocence emerged. Curtis knows this better than anyone, but he also knows that a life of crime made it easier for the state to convict him. It is a rare sight to witness someone so gracefully admit his shortcomings. A high school student asked Curtis, "When you got out of prison, were you angry?"

He replied, "I was angry, in fact I was very angry. I soon realized though that bitterness is unproductive. I wanted to be productive, and I wanted to seek justice. In order to do this, I had to stop being angry and instead tell my story." The story of Curtis McCarty is a story that needs to be told, over and over and over again.

Labels: , , , ,

Comments :
Did Curtis ever mention Janelle Fowler? Did he tell you that Janelle was a 7 year old girl that raped and beaten to death with a baseball bat? Did he tell you that he helped hide her body in a concrete mixer at a gravel pit? Did he tell you that he left her little battered body there for a month until he negotiated for his freedon in exchange for his testimony against the other person involved in her murder? Did he tell you that he took the police to her body and that is how they found her?

There is a lot to the Willis case that I'll bet he didn't tell you either. I'm very curious to know just how truthful he has been. If he isn't telling his audience about this murder, then he isn't telling them everything.
I seriously doubt you are going to post my comments about McCarty, because that would embarass you. But, I think you should know who you are dealing with.

This is an excerpt from Mark Fuhrman's book, Death and Justice. "During the penalty phase, jurors heard testimony that McCarty was involved in the Janelle Fowler murder. Dave Todd Osborne, who had already pleaded guilty to the murder, testified that it was McCarty who had beaten the seven-year-old to death with a baseball bat. "I saw him swing and hit her," Osborne said. "I saw him swing again. He was freaking out."

1998 OK CR 61
___ P.2d ___
Case No. F-96-503
November 6, 1998

David Osborne testified Appellant attempted to rape and then killed seven year old Janelle Fowler; Eddie Thomason, an investigator for the Oklahoma County District Attorney, testified Appellant led him to Janelle Fowler's body; P.N. testified Appellant raped her; and Theodore Edgin testified he overheard Appellant telling cell mates that he and a buddy had sex with a girl, then stabbed and killed her.

¶35 Concerning the testimony of David Osborne and Eddie Thomason, Appellant raises four relevant issues. 24 First, Appellant claims the State entered into a non-prosecution agreement with him concerning Janelle Fowler's murder, thereby granting Appellant full immunity from prosecution. Second, he claims the trial court refused to grant a Jackson v. Denno
¶36 We begin with the extremely complicated circumstances surrounding the non-prosecution agreement. Seven year old Janelle Fowler was murdered on or about September 17, 1983. David Osborne was arrested and charged with the murder the following day. Appellant was interviewed by authorities regarding the murder on November 16, 1983, and he implicated Osborne as the murderer at that time. Appellant showed authorities the approximate location of the child's body on November 16, 1983, but told them he did not know exactly where the body was located. This was a lie. The following day, Appellant took a polygraph test regarding his involvement in the murder. The test results, which are not in the record, apparently indicated he had been truthful, except with respect to questions concerning his involvement in disposing of the child's body. Following receipt of the polygraph results, Appellant led authorities to the body on November 17, 1983.
The law said that this man could no longer be held on Oklahoma's death row. That is what I know.
This comment has been removed by the author.
I knew Janelle a wonderful , beautiful little girl , to bad the electric chair was retired, but then again that would be to good for him.
McCarty didn't mentioned how he raped, and anally/orally sodomized Philamena Neal while he was out on bond waiting to be tried for the murder of Pam Willis. He pled guilty in Cleveland County and was given a 5 year suspended sentence. Barry Albert, then an assistant Oklahoma County D.A., stated publicly that it was such a travesty of justice the District Attorney of Cleveland County should be on trial. Ms. Neal (not her last name now that she is married) testified about the rape and sodomy in the second stage of McCarty's trial. He's not innocent he just got away with his crimes.
Thank you so much for posting the truth about this....person.
Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post :

Create a Link

<< Home